Vrftjkry

Question:

Let X = $({1,2,3,..,10})$ Let $Y$ be a uniformly random subset of $X$. Define the events:

A = “$Y$ contains at least $4$ elements",

B = “all elements of $Y$ are even".

What is $Pr(A|B)$?

Answer: 0.1875

Attempt:

I know that P(A $bigcap$ B) / P(B) is what I have to ultimately find.

For $P(B)$ = $frac{5}{10}$ = $frac{1}{2}$

For P(A) => Must have exactly 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10 elements

So, I used the binomial for this by doing:

P(A) =
$10choose4$$.$ $frac{1}{10}$$^4$$.$$(1-frac{1}{10}$)$^6$ +

$10choose5$$.$ $frac{1}{10}$$^5$$.$$(1-frac{1}{10}$)$^5$ +

$10choose6$$.$ $frac{1}{10}$$^6$$.$$(1-frac{1}{10}$)$^4$ +

$10choose7$$.$ $frac{1}{10}$$^7$$.$$(1-frac{1}{10}$)$^3$ +

$10choose8$$.$ $frac{1}{10}$$^8$$.$$(1-frac{1}{10}$)$^2$ +

$10choose9$$.$ $frac{1}{10}$$^9$$.$$(1-frac{1}{10}$)$^1$ +

$10choose10$$.$ $frac{1}{10}$$^{10}$$.$$(1-frac{1}{10}$)$^0$ +

= $0.012795$

P(A $bigcap$B) = $frac{1}{2}*0.012795$

Pr(A|B) = $frac{frac{1}{2}*0.012795}{2}$

Pr(A|B) = $0.012795$

Where did I go wrong with this approach? I find finding P(A) very time consuming, I feel like there has to be a much more simpler approach.

$5$ elements of $X$ are even.

To have at least $4$ elements and all elements are even, you have either $4$ elements ($5$ ways, choose one to leave out) or $5$ elements ($1$ way).

$$frac{1+5}{2^{5}}=frac{6}{32}$$

Remark:

• We are choosing uniformly over all subsets. $P(B)= frac{2^5}{2^{10}} ne frac{5}{10}$.




• We don't have to find $P(A)$, what is of interest is $P(A cap B)$.




• We do not have $P(A cap B)=P(A)P(B)$ in general, we need independence.

1. Why are you using binomial distribution to evaluate the probabilities for event $A$, when $Y$ is a uniformly random subset of $X$?   That means that every element (ie subset of $X$) of the powerset of $X$ (the sample space) has an equal probability of being selected.   Just count the favoured and total spaces.




2. $mathsf P(Acap B)=mathsf P(B)~mathsf P(A)$ is only true for independent events, of which these are not.   Evaluate $mathsf P(Acap B)$ using a similar method as you should have evaluated $mathsf P(A)$.




3. $mathsf P(B) neq tfrac 12$.   The event of "all the elements of $Y$ are even" is not exactly half of the sample space, which may be partitioned by "all the elements of $Y$ are even", "all of the elements of $Y$ are odd", and "some of the elements of $Y$ are even, and some are odd."   Rethink.