Solving $int_{0}^{infty} frac{sin(x)}{x^3}dx$
up vote
6
down vote
favorite
In my attempt to solve the this improper integral, I employed a well known improper integral (part of the Borwein family of integrals):
$$ int_{0}^{infty} frac{sinleft(frac{x}{1}right)sinleft(frac{x}{3}right)sinleft(frac{x}{5}right)}{left(frac{x}{1}right)left(frac{x}{3}right)left(frac{x}{5}right)} : dx = frac{pi}{2}$$
To begin with, I made a simple rearrangement
$$ int_{0}^{infty} frac{sinleft(frac{x}{1}right)sinleft(frac{x}{3}right)sinleft(frac{x}{5}right)}{x^3} : dx = frac{pi}{30}$$
From here I used the Sine/Cosine Identities
$$ int_{0}^{infty} frac{frac{1}{4}left(-sinleft(frac{7}{15}xright)+ sinleft(frac{13}{15}xright) + sinleft(frac{17}{15}xright) -sinleft(frac{23}{15}xright) right)}{x^3} : dx = frac{pi}{30}$$
Which when expanded becomes
$$ -int_{0}^{infty} frac{sinleft(frac{7}{15}xright)}{x^3}:dx + int_{0}^{infty} frac{sinleft(frac{13}{15}xright)}{x^3}:dx +
int_{0}^{infty} frac{sinleft(frac{17}{15}xright)}{x^3}:dx -
int_{0}^{infty} frac{sinleft(frac{23}{15}xright)}{x^3}:dx
= frac{2pi}{15}$$
Using the property
$$int_{0}^{infty}frac{sin(ax)}{x^3}:dx = a^2 int_{0}^{infty}frac{sin(x)}{x^3}:dx$$
We can reduce our expression to
$$left[ -left(frac{7}{15}right)^2 + left(frac{13}{15}right)^2 + left(frac{17}{15}right)^2 - left(frac{23}{15}right)^2right] int_{0}^{infty} frac{sin(x)}{x^3}:dx = frac{2pi}{15}$$
Which simplifies to
$$ -frac{120}{15^2}int_{0}^{infty} frac{sin(x)}{x^3}:dx = frac{2pi}{15}$$
And from which we arrive at
$$int_{0}^{infty} frac{sin(x)}{x^3}:dx = -frac{pi}{4}$$
Is this correct? I'm not sure but when I plug into Wolframalpha it keeps timing out...
integration improper-integrals
add a comment |
up vote
6
down vote
favorite
In my attempt to solve the this improper integral, I employed a well known improper integral (part of the Borwein family of integrals):
$$ int_{0}^{infty} frac{sinleft(frac{x}{1}right)sinleft(frac{x}{3}right)sinleft(frac{x}{5}right)}{left(frac{x}{1}right)left(frac{x}{3}right)left(frac{x}{5}right)} : dx = frac{pi}{2}$$
To begin with, I made a simple rearrangement
$$ int_{0}^{infty} frac{sinleft(frac{x}{1}right)sinleft(frac{x}{3}right)sinleft(frac{x}{5}right)}{x^3} : dx = frac{pi}{30}$$
From here I used the Sine/Cosine Identities
$$ int_{0}^{infty} frac{frac{1}{4}left(-sinleft(frac{7}{15}xright)+ sinleft(frac{13}{15}xright) + sinleft(frac{17}{15}xright) -sinleft(frac{23}{15}xright) right)}{x^3} : dx = frac{pi}{30}$$
Which when expanded becomes
$$ -int_{0}^{infty} frac{sinleft(frac{7}{15}xright)}{x^3}:dx + int_{0}^{infty} frac{sinleft(frac{13}{15}xright)}{x^3}:dx +
int_{0}^{infty} frac{sinleft(frac{17}{15}xright)}{x^3}:dx -
int_{0}^{infty} frac{sinleft(frac{23}{15}xright)}{x^3}:dx
= frac{2pi}{15}$$
Using the property
$$int_{0}^{infty}frac{sin(ax)}{x^3}:dx = a^2 int_{0}^{infty}frac{sin(x)}{x^3}:dx$$
We can reduce our expression to
$$left[ -left(frac{7}{15}right)^2 + left(frac{13}{15}right)^2 + left(frac{17}{15}right)^2 - left(frac{23}{15}right)^2right] int_{0}^{infty} frac{sin(x)}{x^3}:dx = frac{2pi}{15}$$
Which simplifies to
$$ -frac{120}{15^2}int_{0}^{infty} frac{sin(x)}{x^3}:dx = frac{2pi}{15}$$
And from which we arrive at
$$int_{0}^{infty} frac{sin(x)}{x^3}:dx = -frac{pi}{4}$$
Is this correct? I'm not sure but when I plug into Wolframalpha it keeps timing out...
integration improper-integrals
add a comment |
up vote
6
down vote
favorite
up vote
6
down vote
favorite
In my attempt to solve the this improper integral, I employed a well known improper integral (part of the Borwein family of integrals):
$$ int_{0}^{infty} frac{sinleft(frac{x}{1}right)sinleft(frac{x}{3}right)sinleft(frac{x}{5}right)}{left(frac{x}{1}right)left(frac{x}{3}right)left(frac{x}{5}right)} : dx = frac{pi}{2}$$
To begin with, I made a simple rearrangement
$$ int_{0}^{infty} frac{sinleft(frac{x}{1}right)sinleft(frac{x}{3}right)sinleft(frac{x}{5}right)}{x^3} : dx = frac{pi}{30}$$
From here I used the Sine/Cosine Identities
$$ int_{0}^{infty} frac{frac{1}{4}left(-sinleft(frac{7}{15}xright)+ sinleft(frac{13}{15}xright) + sinleft(frac{17}{15}xright) -sinleft(frac{23}{15}xright) right)}{x^3} : dx = frac{pi}{30}$$
Which when expanded becomes
$$ -int_{0}^{infty} frac{sinleft(frac{7}{15}xright)}{x^3}:dx + int_{0}^{infty} frac{sinleft(frac{13}{15}xright)}{x^3}:dx +
int_{0}^{infty} frac{sinleft(frac{17}{15}xright)}{x^3}:dx -
int_{0}^{infty} frac{sinleft(frac{23}{15}xright)}{x^3}:dx
= frac{2pi}{15}$$
Using the property
$$int_{0}^{infty}frac{sin(ax)}{x^3}:dx = a^2 int_{0}^{infty}frac{sin(x)}{x^3}:dx$$
We can reduce our expression to
$$left[ -left(frac{7}{15}right)^2 + left(frac{13}{15}right)^2 + left(frac{17}{15}right)^2 - left(frac{23}{15}right)^2right] int_{0}^{infty} frac{sin(x)}{x^3}:dx = frac{2pi}{15}$$
Which simplifies to
$$ -frac{120}{15^2}int_{0}^{infty} frac{sin(x)}{x^3}:dx = frac{2pi}{15}$$
And from which we arrive at
$$int_{0}^{infty} frac{sin(x)}{x^3}:dx = -frac{pi}{4}$$
Is this correct? I'm not sure but when I plug into Wolframalpha it keeps timing out...
integration improper-integrals
In my attempt to solve the this improper integral, I employed a well known improper integral (part of the Borwein family of integrals):
$$ int_{0}^{infty} frac{sinleft(frac{x}{1}right)sinleft(frac{x}{3}right)sinleft(frac{x}{5}right)}{left(frac{x}{1}right)left(frac{x}{3}right)left(frac{x}{5}right)} : dx = frac{pi}{2}$$
To begin with, I made a simple rearrangement
$$ int_{0}^{infty} frac{sinleft(frac{x}{1}right)sinleft(frac{x}{3}right)sinleft(frac{x}{5}right)}{x^3} : dx = frac{pi}{30}$$
From here I used the Sine/Cosine Identities
$$ int_{0}^{infty} frac{frac{1}{4}left(-sinleft(frac{7}{15}xright)+ sinleft(frac{13}{15}xright) + sinleft(frac{17}{15}xright) -sinleft(frac{23}{15}xright) right)}{x^3} : dx = frac{pi}{30}$$
Which when expanded becomes
$$ -int_{0}^{infty} frac{sinleft(frac{7}{15}xright)}{x^3}:dx + int_{0}^{infty} frac{sinleft(frac{13}{15}xright)}{x^3}:dx +
int_{0}^{infty} frac{sinleft(frac{17}{15}xright)}{x^3}:dx -
int_{0}^{infty} frac{sinleft(frac{23}{15}xright)}{x^3}:dx
= frac{2pi}{15}$$
Using the property
$$int_{0}^{infty}frac{sin(ax)}{x^3}:dx = a^2 int_{0}^{infty}frac{sin(x)}{x^3}:dx$$
We can reduce our expression to
$$left[ -left(frac{7}{15}right)^2 + left(frac{13}{15}right)^2 + left(frac{17}{15}right)^2 - left(frac{23}{15}right)^2right] int_{0}^{infty} frac{sin(x)}{x^3}:dx = frac{2pi}{15}$$
Which simplifies to
$$ -frac{120}{15^2}int_{0}^{infty} frac{sin(x)}{x^3}:dx = frac{2pi}{15}$$
And from which we arrive at
$$int_{0}^{infty} frac{sin(x)}{x^3}:dx = -frac{pi}{4}$$
Is this correct? I'm not sure but when I plug into Wolframalpha it keeps timing out...
integration improper-integrals
integration improper-integrals
asked Nov 16 at 4:49
DavidG
803513
803513
add a comment |
add a comment |
3 Answers
3
active
oldest
votes
up vote
6
down vote
accepted
$$-int_{0}^{infty} frac{sinleft(frac{7}{15}xright)}{x^3}:dx + int_{0}^{infty} frac{sinleft(frac{13}{15}xright)}{x^3}:dx +
int_{0}^{infty} frac{sinleft(frac{17}{15}xright)}{x^3}:dx -
int_{0}^{infty} frac{sinleft(frac{23}{15}xright)}{x^3}:dx
= frac{2pi}{15}$$
You cannot expand the integrals since they are not convergent.
Moreover, given that $int_a^b f(x)+g(x)dx$ converges,
$int_a^b f(x)+g(x)dx=int_a^b f(x)dx+int_a^b g(x)dx$ only if $int_a^b f(x)dx$ and $int_a^b g(x)dx$ converge.
1
Thank you! That's exactly what I was looking for! Is there a theorem for that property? and if so, do you know the name?
– DavidG
Nov 16 at 4:59
1
This is a basic property of integration. I'm sorry I don't know the name.
– Kemono Chen
Nov 16 at 5:00
No worries. Thanks for your post. Much appreciated.
– DavidG
Nov 16 at 5:00
add a comment |
up vote
6
down vote
begin{multline}
int_0^infty frac{sin(x)}{x^3}dx = int_0^1 frac{sin(x)}{x^3}dx +int_1^infty frac{sin(x)}{x^3}dx \> int_0^1 frac{x/2}{x^3}dx +int_1^infty frac{sin(x)}{x^3}dx = frac{1}{2}int_0^1 frac{1}{x^2}dx +int_1^infty frac{sin(x)}{x^3}dx = infty
end{multline}
The integral diverges.
I thought that was the case. What can we say of the result above then? What mistake(s) have I made?
– DavidG
Nov 16 at 4:57
1
@DavidG The error was the separation of the four integrals. Each one individually diverges--the integrand only converges in the full integral because the divergent parts of the sum cancel out.
– eyeballfrog
Nov 16 at 4:59
Yes Kemono Chen just commented that. Do you know the name of the Theorem that speaks to the invalidity of the expansion in this case?
– DavidG
Nov 16 at 5:00
1
@DavidG I don't know that there is a name for it. Just a general note of caution to always check for convergence before doing things in calculus.
– eyeballfrog
Nov 16 at 5:04
I will indeed. Thanks again for your post.
– DavidG
Nov 16 at 5:05
add a comment |
up vote
4
down vote
As the other answers have pointed out, the integral does indeed diverge. But if want to assign a finite value to it, there are a couple ways to see that in fact $-pi/4$ is the "right" value.
One is to take the integral not quite down to zero, but instead to $epsilon$. If we do, then expand in a series in $epsilon$, we get
$$int_epsilon^inftyfrac{sin x}{x^3},dx=epsilon^{-1}-frac{pi}{4}+O(epsilon).$$
The leading term is the divergent $epsilon^{-1}$, but if we ignore that then the next term is $-pi/4$.
Another way to get the same value is to first extend the integral to $-infty$. Since the integrand is even, we would expect
$$int_0^inftyfrac{sin x}{x^3},dx=frac12int_{-infty}^inftyfrac{sin x}{x^3},dx.$$
Of course, the right-hand integral diverges, as well. But the only problem point is when $x=0$. If we imagine $x$ as being in the complex plane, travelling from $-infty$ to $infty$, then we can just "go around" $0$ by curving $x$ slightly out into the complex plane, for example:
If we do, then we end up with the same answer of $-pi/4$. I'm not sure what this sort of regularization is called, but it's frequently used in quantum field theory where divergent integrals abound.
Thanks so much for that post - fascinating stuff. I'm sure I'm wrong in comparing the two, but it reminds me of the $sum_{i}^{infty} i = -frac{1}{12}$ where if we 'ignore' a certain rule in the Field of Reals we get an answer that has value in String Theory. I often wonder if that's because we are yet to discover the link that allows this incorrect result to be correct... in the same way that Complex Numbers allowed us to understand aspects of Real Numbers. But hey, maybe I'm just a dreamer.
– DavidG
Nov 16 at 7:37
add a comment |
3 Answers
3
active
oldest
votes
3 Answers
3
active
oldest
votes
active
oldest
votes
active
oldest
votes
up vote
6
down vote
accepted
$$-int_{0}^{infty} frac{sinleft(frac{7}{15}xright)}{x^3}:dx + int_{0}^{infty} frac{sinleft(frac{13}{15}xright)}{x^3}:dx +
int_{0}^{infty} frac{sinleft(frac{17}{15}xright)}{x^3}:dx -
int_{0}^{infty} frac{sinleft(frac{23}{15}xright)}{x^3}:dx
= frac{2pi}{15}$$
You cannot expand the integrals since they are not convergent.
Moreover, given that $int_a^b f(x)+g(x)dx$ converges,
$int_a^b f(x)+g(x)dx=int_a^b f(x)dx+int_a^b g(x)dx$ only if $int_a^b f(x)dx$ and $int_a^b g(x)dx$ converge.
1
Thank you! That's exactly what I was looking for! Is there a theorem for that property? and if so, do you know the name?
– DavidG
Nov 16 at 4:59
1
This is a basic property of integration. I'm sorry I don't know the name.
– Kemono Chen
Nov 16 at 5:00
No worries. Thanks for your post. Much appreciated.
– DavidG
Nov 16 at 5:00
add a comment |
up vote
6
down vote
accepted
$$-int_{0}^{infty} frac{sinleft(frac{7}{15}xright)}{x^3}:dx + int_{0}^{infty} frac{sinleft(frac{13}{15}xright)}{x^3}:dx +
int_{0}^{infty} frac{sinleft(frac{17}{15}xright)}{x^3}:dx -
int_{0}^{infty} frac{sinleft(frac{23}{15}xright)}{x^3}:dx
= frac{2pi}{15}$$
You cannot expand the integrals since they are not convergent.
Moreover, given that $int_a^b f(x)+g(x)dx$ converges,
$int_a^b f(x)+g(x)dx=int_a^b f(x)dx+int_a^b g(x)dx$ only if $int_a^b f(x)dx$ and $int_a^b g(x)dx$ converge.
1
Thank you! That's exactly what I was looking for! Is there a theorem for that property? and if so, do you know the name?
– DavidG
Nov 16 at 4:59
1
This is a basic property of integration. I'm sorry I don't know the name.
– Kemono Chen
Nov 16 at 5:00
No worries. Thanks for your post. Much appreciated.
– DavidG
Nov 16 at 5:00
add a comment |
up vote
6
down vote
accepted
up vote
6
down vote
accepted
$$-int_{0}^{infty} frac{sinleft(frac{7}{15}xright)}{x^3}:dx + int_{0}^{infty} frac{sinleft(frac{13}{15}xright)}{x^3}:dx +
int_{0}^{infty} frac{sinleft(frac{17}{15}xright)}{x^3}:dx -
int_{0}^{infty} frac{sinleft(frac{23}{15}xright)}{x^3}:dx
= frac{2pi}{15}$$
You cannot expand the integrals since they are not convergent.
Moreover, given that $int_a^b f(x)+g(x)dx$ converges,
$int_a^b f(x)+g(x)dx=int_a^b f(x)dx+int_a^b g(x)dx$ only if $int_a^b f(x)dx$ and $int_a^b g(x)dx$ converge.
$$-int_{0}^{infty} frac{sinleft(frac{7}{15}xright)}{x^3}:dx + int_{0}^{infty} frac{sinleft(frac{13}{15}xright)}{x^3}:dx +
int_{0}^{infty} frac{sinleft(frac{17}{15}xright)}{x^3}:dx -
int_{0}^{infty} frac{sinleft(frac{23}{15}xright)}{x^3}:dx
= frac{2pi}{15}$$
You cannot expand the integrals since they are not convergent.
Moreover, given that $int_a^b f(x)+g(x)dx$ converges,
$int_a^b f(x)+g(x)dx=int_a^b f(x)dx+int_a^b g(x)dx$ only if $int_a^b f(x)dx$ and $int_a^b g(x)dx$ converge.
edited Nov 16 at 5:34
Masacroso
12.2k41746
12.2k41746
answered Nov 16 at 4:58
Kemono Chen
1,606330
1,606330
1
Thank you! That's exactly what I was looking for! Is there a theorem for that property? and if so, do you know the name?
– DavidG
Nov 16 at 4:59
1
This is a basic property of integration. I'm sorry I don't know the name.
– Kemono Chen
Nov 16 at 5:00
No worries. Thanks for your post. Much appreciated.
– DavidG
Nov 16 at 5:00
add a comment |
1
Thank you! That's exactly what I was looking for! Is there a theorem for that property? and if so, do you know the name?
– DavidG
Nov 16 at 4:59
1
This is a basic property of integration. I'm sorry I don't know the name.
– Kemono Chen
Nov 16 at 5:00
No worries. Thanks for your post. Much appreciated.
– DavidG
Nov 16 at 5:00
1
1
Thank you! That's exactly what I was looking for! Is there a theorem for that property? and if so, do you know the name?
– DavidG
Nov 16 at 4:59
Thank you! That's exactly what I was looking for! Is there a theorem for that property? and if so, do you know the name?
– DavidG
Nov 16 at 4:59
1
1
This is a basic property of integration. I'm sorry I don't know the name.
– Kemono Chen
Nov 16 at 5:00
This is a basic property of integration. I'm sorry I don't know the name.
– Kemono Chen
Nov 16 at 5:00
No worries. Thanks for your post. Much appreciated.
– DavidG
Nov 16 at 5:00
No worries. Thanks for your post. Much appreciated.
– DavidG
Nov 16 at 5:00
add a comment |
up vote
6
down vote
begin{multline}
int_0^infty frac{sin(x)}{x^3}dx = int_0^1 frac{sin(x)}{x^3}dx +int_1^infty frac{sin(x)}{x^3}dx \> int_0^1 frac{x/2}{x^3}dx +int_1^infty frac{sin(x)}{x^3}dx = frac{1}{2}int_0^1 frac{1}{x^2}dx +int_1^infty frac{sin(x)}{x^3}dx = infty
end{multline}
The integral diverges.
I thought that was the case. What can we say of the result above then? What mistake(s) have I made?
– DavidG
Nov 16 at 4:57
1
@DavidG The error was the separation of the four integrals. Each one individually diverges--the integrand only converges in the full integral because the divergent parts of the sum cancel out.
– eyeballfrog
Nov 16 at 4:59
Yes Kemono Chen just commented that. Do you know the name of the Theorem that speaks to the invalidity of the expansion in this case?
– DavidG
Nov 16 at 5:00
1
@DavidG I don't know that there is a name for it. Just a general note of caution to always check for convergence before doing things in calculus.
– eyeballfrog
Nov 16 at 5:04
I will indeed. Thanks again for your post.
– DavidG
Nov 16 at 5:05
add a comment |
up vote
6
down vote
begin{multline}
int_0^infty frac{sin(x)}{x^3}dx = int_0^1 frac{sin(x)}{x^3}dx +int_1^infty frac{sin(x)}{x^3}dx \> int_0^1 frac{x/2}{x^3}dx +int_1^infty frac{sin(x)}{x^3}dx = frac{1}{2}int_0^1 frac{1}{x^2}dx +int_1^infty frac{sin(x)}{x^3}dx = infty
end{multline}
The integral diverges.
I thought that was the case. What can we say of the result above then? What mistake(s) have I made?
– DavidG
Nov 16 at 4:57
1
@DavidG The error was the separation of the four integrals. Each one individually diverges--the integrand only converges in the full integral because the divergent parts of the sum cancel out.
– eyeballfrog
Nov 16 at 4:59
Yes Kemono Chen just commented that. Do you know the name of the Theorem that speaks to the invalidity of the expansion in this case?
– DavidG
Nov 16 at 5:00
1
@DavidG I don't know that there is a name for it. Just a general note of caution to always check for convergence before doing things in calculus.
– eyeballfrog
Nov 16 at 5:04
I will indeed. Thanks again for your post.
– DavidG
Nov 16 at 5:05
add a comment |
up vote
6
down vote
up vote
6
down vote
begin{multline}
int_0^infty frac{sin(x)}{x^3}dx = int_0^1 frac{sin(x)}{x^3}dx +int_1^infty frac{sin(x)}{x^3}dx \> int_0^1 frac{x/2}{x^3}dx +int_1^infty frac{sin(x)}{x^3}dx = frac{1}{2}int_0^1 frac{1}{x^2}dx +int_1^infty frac{sin(x)}{x^3}dx = infty
end{multline}
The integral diverges.
begin{multline}
int_0^infty frac{sin(x)}{x^3}dx = int_0^1 frac{sin(x)}{x^3}dx +int_1^infty frac{sin(x)}{x^3}dx \> int_0^1 frac{x/2}{x^3}dx +int_1^infty frac{sin(x)}{x^3}dx = frac{1}{2}int_0^1 frac{1}{x^2}dx +int_1^infty frac{sin(x)}{x^3}dx = infty
end{multline}
The integral diverges.
answered Nov 16 at 4:56
eyeballfrog
5,678528
5,678528
I thought that was the case. What can we say of the result above then? What mistake(s) have I made?
– DavidG
Nov 16 at 4:57
1
@DavidG The error was the separation of the four integrals. Each one individually diverges--the integrand only converges in the full integral because the divergent parts of the sum cancel out.
– eyeballfrog
Nov 16 at 4:59
Yes Kemono Chen just commented that. Do you know the name of the Theorem that speaks to the invalidity of the expansion in this case?
– DavidG
Nov 16 at 5:00
1
@DavidG I don't know that there is a name for it. Just a general note of caution to always check for convergence before doing things in calculus.
– eyeballfrog
Nov 16 at 5:04
I will indeed. Thanks again for your post.
– DavidG
Nov 16 at 5:05
add a comment |
I thought that was the case. What can we say of the result above then? What mistake(s) have I made?
– DavidG
Nov 16 at 4:57
1
@DavidG The error was the separation of the four integrals. Each one individually diverges--the integrand only converges in the full integral because the divergent parts of the sum cancel out.
– eyeballfrog
Nov 16 at 4:59
Yes Kemono Chen just commented that. Do you know the name of the Theorem that speaks to the invalidity of the expansion in this case?
– DavidG
Nov 16 at 5:00
1
@DavidG I don't know that there is a name for it. Just a general note of caution to always check for convergence before doing things in calculus.
– eyeballfrog
Nov 16 at 5:04
I will indeed. Thanks again for your post.
– DavidG
Nov 16 at 5:05
I thought that was the case. What can we say of the result above then? What mistake(s) have I made?
– DavidG
Nov 16 at 4:57
I thought that was the case. What can we say of the result above then? What mistake(s) have I made?
– DavidG
Nov 16 at 4:57
1
1
@DavidG The error was the separation of the four integrals. Each one individually diverges--the integrand only converges in the full integral because the divergent parts of the sum cancel out.
– eyeballfrog
Nov 16 at 4:59
@DavidG The error was the separation of the four integrals. Each one individually diverges--the integrand only converges in the full integral because the divergent parts of the sum cancel out.
– eyeballfrog
Nov 16 at 4:59
Yes Kemono Chen just commented that. Do you know the name of the Theorem that speaks to the invalidity of the expansion in this case?
– DavidG
Nov 16 at 5:00
Yes Kemono Chen just commented that. Do you know the name of the Theorem that speaks to the invalidity of the expansion in this case?
– DavidG
Nov 16 at 5:00
1
1
@DavidG I don't know that there is a name for it. Just a general note of caution to always check for convergence before doing things in calculus.
– eyeballfrog
Nov 16 at 5:04
@DavidG I don't know that there is a name for it. Just a general note of caution to always check for convergence before doing things in calculus.
– eyeballfrog
Nov 16 at 5:04
I will indeed. Thanks again for your post.
– DavidG
Nov 16 at 5:05
I will indeed. Thanks again for your post.
– DavidG
Nov 16 at 5:05
add a comment |
up vote
4
down vote
As the other answers have pointed out, the integral does indeed diverge. But if want to assign a finite value to it, there are a couple ways to see that in fact $-pi/4$ is the "right" value.
One is to take the integral not quite down to zero, but instead to $epsilon$. If we do, then expand in a series in $epsilon$, we get
$$int_epsilon^inftyfrac{sin x}{x^3},dx=epsilon^{-1}-frac{pi}{4}+O(epsilon).$$
The leading term is the divergent $epsilon^{-1}$, but if we ignore that then the next term is $-pi/4$.
Another way to get the same value is to first extend the integral to $-infty$. Since the integrand is even, we would expect
$$int_0^inftyfrac{sin x}{x^3},dx=frac12int_{-infty}^inftyfrac{sin x}{x^3},dx.$$
Of course, the right-hand integral diverges, as well. But the only problem point is when $x=0$. If we imagine $x$ as being in the complex plane, travelling from $-infty$ to $infty$, then we can just "go around" $0$ by curving $x$ slightly out into the complex plane, for example:
If we do, then we end up with the same answer of $-pi/4$. I'm not sure what this sort of regularization is called, but it's frequently used in quantum field theory where divergent integrals abound.
Thanks so much for that post - fascinating stuff. I'm sure I'm wrong in comparing the two, but it reminds me of the $sum_{i}^{infty} i = -frac{1}{12}$ where if we 'ignore' a certain rule in the Field of Reals we get an answer that has value in String Theory. I often wonder if that's because we are yet to discover the link that allows this incorrect result to be correct... in the same way that Complex Numbers allowed us to understand aspects of Real Numbers. But hey, maybe I'm just a dreamer.
– DavidG
Nov 16 at 7:37
add a comment |
up vote
4
down vote
As the other answers have pointed out, the integral does indeed diverge. But if want to assign a finite value to it, there are a couple ways to see that in fact $-pi/4$ is the "right" value.
One is to take the integral not quite down to zero, but instead to $epsilon$. If we do, then expand in a series in $epsilon$, we get
$$int_epsilon^inftyfrac{sin x}{x^3},dx=epsilon^{-1}-frac{pi}{4}+O(epsilon).$$
The leading term is the divergent $epsilon^{-1}$, but if we ignore that then the next term is $-pi/4$.
Another way to get the same value is to first extend the integral to $-infty$. Since the integrand is even, we would expect
$$int_0^inftyfrac{sin x}{x^3},dx=frac12int_{-infty}^inftyfrac{sin x}{x^3},dx.$$
Of course, the right-hand integral diverges, as well. But the only problem point is when $x=0$. If we imagine $x$ as being in the complex plane, travelling from $-infty$ to $infty$, then we can just "go around" $0$ by curving $x$ slightly out into the complex plane, for example:
If we do, then we end up with the same answer of $-pi/4$. I'm not sure what this sort of regularization is called, but it's frequently used in quantum field theory where divergent integrals abound.
Thanks so much for that post - fascinating stuff. I'm sure I'm wrong in comparing the two, but it reminds me of the $sum_{i}^{infty} i = -frac{1}{12}$ where if we 'ignore' a certain rule in the Field of Reals we get an answer that has value in String Theory. I often wonder if that's because we are yet to discover the link that allows this incorrect result to be correct... in the same way that Complex Numbers allowed us to understand aspects of Real Numbers. But hey, maybe I'm just a dreamer.
– DavidG
Nov 16 at 7:37
add a comment |
up vote
4
down vote
up vote
4
down vote
As the other answers have pointed out, the integral does indeed diverge. But if want to assign a finite value to it, there are a couple ways to see that in fact $-pi/4$ is the "right" value.
One is to take the integral not quite down to zero, but instead to $epsilon$. If we do, then expand in a series in $epsilon$, we get
$$int_epsilon^inftyfrac{sin x}{x^3},dx=epsilon^{-1}-frac{pi}{4}+O(epsilon).$$
The leading term is the divergent $epsilon^{-1}$, but if we ignore that then the next term is $-pi/4$.
Another way to get the same value is to first extend the integral to $-infty$. Since the integrand is even, we would expect
$$int_0^inftyfrac{sin x}{x^3},dx=frac12int_{-infty}^inftyfrac{sin x}{x^3},dx.$$
Of course, the right-hand integral diverges, as well. But the only problem point is when $x=0$. If we imagine $x$ as being in the complex plane, travelling from $-infty$ to $infty$, then we can just "go around" $0$ by curving $x$ slightly out into the complex plane, for example:
If we do, then we end up with the same answer of $-pi/4$. I'm not sure what this sort of regularization is called, but it's frequently used in quantum field theory where divergent integrals abound.
As the other answers have pointed out, the integral does indeed diverge. But if want to assign a finite value to it, there are a couple ways to see that in fact $-pi/4$ is the "right" value.
One is to take the integral not quite down to zero, but instead to $epsilon$. If we do, then expand in a series in $epsilon$, we get
$$int_epsilon^inftyfrac{sin x}{x^3},dx=epsilon^{-1}-frac{pi}{4}+O(epsilon).$$
The leading term is the divergent $epsilon^{-1}$, but if we ignore that then the next term is $-pi/4$.
Another way to get the same value is to first extend the integral to $-infty$. Since the integrand is even, we would expect
$$int_0^inftyfrac{sin x}{x^3},dx=frac12int_{-infty}^inftyfrac{sin x}{x^3},dx.$$
Of course, the right-hand integral diverges, as well. But the only problem point is when $x=0$. If we imagine $x$ as being in the complex plane, travelling from $-infty$ to $infty$, then we can just "go around" $0$ by curving $x$ slightly out into the complex plane, for example:
If we do, then we end up with the same answer of $-pi/4$. I'm not sure what this sort of regularization is called, but it's frequently used in quantum field theory where divergent integrals abound.
answered Nov 16 at 6:50
Carmeister
2,5492920
2,5492920
Thanks so much for that post - fascinating stuff. I'm sure I'm wrong in comparing the two, but it reminds me of the $sum_{i}^{infty} i = -frac{1}{12}$ where if we 'ignore' a certain rule in the Field of Reals we get an answer that has value in String Theory. I often wonder if that's because we are yet to discover the link that allows this incorrect result to be correct... in the same way that Complex Numbers allowed us to understand aspects of Real Numbers. But hey, maybe I'm just a dreamer.
– DavidG
Nov 16 at 7:37
add a comment |
Thanks so much for that post - fascinating stuff. I'm sure I'm wrong in comparing the two, but it reminds me of the $sum_{i}^{infty} i = -frac{1}{12}$ where if we 'ignore' a certain rule in the Field of Reals we get an answer that has value in String Theory. I often wonder if that's because we are yet to discover the link that allows this incorrect result to be correct... in the same way that Complex Numbers allowed us to understand aspects of Real Numbers. But hey, maybe I'm just a dreamer.
– DavidG
Nov 16 at 7:37
Thanks so much for that post - fascinating stuff. I'm sure I'm wrong in comparing the two, but it reminds me of the $sum_{i}^{infty} i = -frac{1}{12}$ where if we 'ignore' a certain rule in the Field of Reals we get an answer that has value in String Theory. I often wonder if that's because we are yet to discover the link that allows this incorrect result to be correct... in the same way that Complex Numbers allowed us to understand aspects of Real Numbers. But hey, maybe I'm just a dreamer.
– DavidG
Nov 16 at 7:37
Thanks so much for that post - fascinating stuff. I'm sure I'm wrong in comparing the two, but it reminds me of the $sum_{i}^{infty} i = -frac{1}{12}$ where if we 'ignore' a certain rule in the Field of Reals we get an answer that has value in String Theory. I often wonder if that's because we are yet to discover the link that allows this incorrect result to be correct... in the same way that Complex Numbers allowed us to understand aspects of Real Numbers. But hey, maybe I'm just a dreamer.
– DavidG
Nov 16 at 7:37
add a comment |
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function () {
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
});
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
StackExchange.ready(
function () {
StackExchange.openid.initPostLogin('.new-post-login', 'https%3a%2f%2fmath.stackexchange.com%2fquestions%2f3000733%2fsolving-int-0-infty-frac-sinxx3dx%23new-answer', 'question_page');
}
);
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function () {
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
});
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function () {
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
});
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function () {
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
});
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown